Web censorship in Finland

Thursday, February 21, 2008 at 4:28 | Posted in censorship, Finland, Freedom of speech, information, internet, transparency | 4 Comments
Tags: ,

When you talk about governments censoring the Internet, you would be most likely to think of countries like China, North Korea, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Cuba etc. As I wrote in my previous post, an attempt to block a whistle blower site was recently made by the US judicial branch. As it turns out, Finland has also joined the notorious countries where government agencies under the noble pretext of fighting child pornography are actually blocking a large number of sites that have nothing to do with child pornography.

Some of the censored sites just incidentally happen to be critical about the censorship itself, including this one operated by Matti Nikki. Matti explains exhaustively in English about the background of his site and the censorship issue. Additional information in English and related links can be found in this article by Electronic Frontier Finland.

The Finnish Parliament last year past a legislation in 2006 allowing the National Bureau of Investigation to comply a list of foreign based web sites allegedly including child pornography. The list was supposed to be sent to Internet service providers together with a request to block access to the listed sites. The black list was supposed to be strictly targeted.

Anybody trying to access the listed URL’s in Finland was supposed to be directed to a NBI page informing about the denied access (here displayed by Matti Nikki). Since my ISP has not (yet?) implied the filter, I am currently able to access both Matti’s site and every other black listed site. I am among other things able to establish that blocking all of the Japanese web portal www.iij4u.or.jp can hardly be described as “strictly targeted filtering”. Among other censored sites I fail to understand what this Japanese music store may have to do with child pornography.

The NBI refuse to comment their black list in public. They also refuse to answer the obvious question why they have not made the courtesy of e-mailing their colleagues in the FBI and European law enforcing agencies about sites actually containing child pornography. One must assume they have not informed their colleagues as the sites are still visible. That also raises the obvious question whether their intention was not to block legitimate critical web contents rather than child pornography.

Electronic Frontiers Finland has filed a complaint to the Chancellor of Justice about the legality of the NBI filter list. The complete complaint (in Finnish) can be accessed here. Among their many questions to the Chancellor is how come Matti Nikki’s site landed on the list although it is completely based in Finland and the law allows only foreign based sites to be filtered.


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

  1. […] enese sissekanded soome ja inglise […]

  2. […] nettisensuurilaki. Susanna Huovinen on siten henkilökohtaisesti syyllinen siihen, että Suomi rinnastetaan Kiinaan, Pohjois-Koreaan, Saudi-Arabiaan ja muihin sosialidemokratioihin netin […]

  3. In order “to protect” they are actually just take our rights away.
    Children are not being protected as it never was their aim anyway.
    They took 4 of my computers.The police lied under oath. Forged evidence and lied about the voice print. It’s a huge story and on it’s way to ECHR. I was in jail when the troll posted and anywhere in the world it would have been the best alibi. Guess what? Guilty.
    The cops accuse me of posting through AOL-UK but I live in Finland and according to AOL you can’t use AOL Internet without the AOL client software installed on your computer. I never had the AOL client.
    On top of that they most likely sold my computers and with it went 4 1/2 years of my work worth 50.000 Euro. I don’t get a cent.
    I know sounds confusing but the whole story would take many pages

  4. Maybe you would like to post it onto your own site. I would like to read the whole story so you are welcome to post a link here.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.
Entries and comments feeds.

%d bloggers like this: